Skip to Content

Why These 20 Fruit Trees Failed Me (And The Reliable Alternatives That Didn’t)

Why These 20 Fruit Trees Failed Me (And The Reliable Alternatives That Didn’t)

Sharing is caring!

Welcome to my fruit tree fiasco! I’ve had my fair share of gardening dreams—only to watch them wither away thanks to some seriously stubborn fruit trees. But hey, every failure taught me a lesson (and gave me a story worth telling). I’m here to share the hilarious misadventures of fruit trees that just didn’t make the cut and the alternatives that saved the day. If you’re up for some laughs and a few gardening tips, you’re in for a treat. I promise it’s more fun than it sounds!

1. Apple Tree

© Reddit

Oh, the apple tree saga! My first attempt at an apple tree was nothing short of tragic. It seemed more interested in growing leaves than producing any apples. I remember joking that it was an apple tree in disguise as a leaf tree.

Then came the star performer, the Fuji apple tree. It was like the apple fairy waved its wand! My garden was suddenly the talk of the town with juicy apples abounding. The Fuji variety loves a sunny spot, so perhaps that was the secret.

If you’re pondering your own apple orchard, Fuji might be your trusty sidekick.

2. Pear Tree

© Reddit

The pear tree was another story of heartbreak. It was as if the tree and I were in a silent film, watching its leaves flutter to the ground, leaving behind a barren, twig-like structure.

The Bartlett pear tree. This beauty showed up and saved the day. With pears that were as sweet as victory itself! It seemed to enjoy the well-drained soil I provided it, a picky little diva.

For anyone with pear dreams, the Bartlett might just be the star performer you’ve been searching for.

3. Plum Tree

© Reddit

Ah, the plum tree that wasn’t meant to be. It stood there, looking like a confused stick, producing plums you’d need a microscope to see. I often said this tree was on a plum strike!

Thankfully, the Santa Rosa plum tree took center stage, showering us with plums that made my heart sing! This variety seemed to love the spot our first plum tree didn’t.

When choosing a plum tree, consider the Santa Rosa for a juicy success story.

4. Cherry Tree

© Reddit

The cherry tree was a real heartbreaker. I had dreams of cherry pies, but unfortunately, the tree had other plans. It looked more like a designer tree with its blossoms.

Then came the Bing cherry tree, the hero of my cherry escapades. Suddenly, cherries were raining like tiny rubies in my garden! Bing trees love the sun and a bit of shade, a combo that worked magic for me.

If cherries are on your mind, Bing might be the cherry on top of your gardening journey.

5. Peach Tree

© Reddit

The drama queen of my garden. Its branches broke under the slightest breeze, and the peaches, if any, were pitiful. It was like hosting a peach-less garden party.

But then came the Elberta peach tree, with peaches that were like little gifts. This one enjoyed a good pruning session, which kept it happy and productive.

The Elberta might just steal the show.

6. Apricot Tree

© Reddit

I had high hopes for my apricot tree, but it seemed to have a different agenda. The leaves drooped like they were practicing a new yoga pose, and the apricots? Nowhere to be seen!

Then, the Tomcot apricot tree came in like a knight in shining armor, producing apricots that seemed to glow in the sun. It thrived with a little extra tlc and a good mulching.

For apricot enthusiasts, the Tomcot might just be the reliable friend you’ve been waiting for.

7. Fig Tree

© Reddit

This tree was more about leaves than figs, as if it was auditioning for a leafy fashion show. Every day I hoped for figs, but was left with leaves, leaves, and more leaves!

Consider Brown Turkey fig tree. It will turn things around with figs. It appreciated a sunny spot and well-drained soil, which seemed to do the trick.

For fig lovers, the Brown Turkey variety could be your ticket to a fruitful adventure.

8. Orange Tree

© Reddit

The orange tree was a sour chapter in my gardening story. I had a tree that was all branches and no fruit.

Valencia orange tree might solve that issue. Bringing oranges that were practically begging to be juiced. This tree seemed to love the warm, sunny spot in my garden.

If you dream of fresh-squeezed orange juice, the Valencia might just be your reliable partner in crime.

9. Lemon Tree

© Reddit

The lemon tree seemed to exist solely to test my patience, with branches that offered more shade than lemons.

My recommendation is the Eureka lemon tree. I had more lemons than I knew what to do with. It enjoyed the sunny, sheltered spot in my garden, an arrangement that seemed to please its citrusy soul.

 Try a Eureka, and you might just find lemonade on the horizon!

10. Lime Tree

© Reddit

This one was a mystery wrapped in a riddle. Leaves drooped, flowers were shy, and limes? Nowhere to be found.

But luckily, Persian lime tree transformed my garden it into a lime paradise! It loved the sunny spot I found, and the well-draining soil seemed to be its secret potion.

For those dreaming of limey cocktails or key lime pies, the Persian lime might be the companion you need.

11. Grapefruit Tree

© Reddit

A citrusy enigma. It stood there fruitless, as if contemplating the meaning of life instead of producing grapefruits.

Along came the Ruby Red grapefruit tree. It appreciated the well-lit, sunny area, reviving my faith in citrus fruits.

 If grapefruits are your thing, the Ruby Red might be what you are looking for.

12. Banana Plant

© Reddit

This one felt more like a banana tease. Leaves tattered by the wind and not a banana in sight.

But the Cavendish banana plant turned things around with bananas that were delightfully sweet. It thrived in the warm, humid spot I found for it.

If you’re yearning for homegrown bananas, the Cavendish might be the golden ticket you’ve been looking for.

13. Mango Tree

© Reddit

A fruitless wanderer. Its branches looked more like abstract art than a mango-producing machine.

Then, the Alphonso mango tree made its debut, gracing me with mangoes that tasted incredible. It loved the sunny, slightly sheltered corner of my garden.

If mangoes are your muse, the Alphonso might be the tree that makes your dreams come true.

14. Papaya Tree

© Reddit

The papaya tree was more about suspense than results. Leaves wilted, and it offered a fruitless vigil year after year.

For me, Red Lady papaya tree stepped in with papayas that were a feast for the senses. It thrived in the well-drained, sunny spot I chose, reviving my papaya aspirations.

For papaya enthusiasts, the Red Lady might be the refreshing alternative you’ve been seeking.

15. Pomegranate Tree

© Reddit

This tree was a puzzle for me. Leaves, no fruit, and plenty of head-scratching moments as I questioned its purpose.

The Wonderful pomegranate tree. It gave my garden pomegranates bursting with seeds and flavor. It loved the sunny, slightly dry spot I selected, rewarding me with a incredible harvest.

The Wonderful variety could be the answer to your gardening prayers. You definitely won’t regret it!

16. Avocado Tree

© Reddit

The avocado tree was the ultimate tease. It promised guacamole but delivered disappointment with its branches and no avocados in sight.

Then the Hass avocado tree arrived, saving the day with avocados that were as rich as they were plentiful. It enjoyed being under the warm sun, in well-drained soil. Safe to say that it became the champion of my garden.

The Hass could be your go-to tree for creamy, delicious fruits. And those guacamole dishes!

17. Pineapple Plant

© Reddit

This one had me questioning my tropical ambitions. Leaves drooped like they’d given up, and pineapples? Not a single one to be found.

Thanks to the MD-2 pineapple plant, I got pineapples that were sweet and succulent. It loved the sunny, well-drained area. Easy as much as it is tasty.

If you’re dreaming of homegrown pineapples, the MD-2 might be the fruity friend you’ve been searching for.

18. Grapevine

© Reddit

The grapevine was a tangled web of disappointment. No grapes and plenty of frustration as I tried to untangle the mystery.

But then I discovered the Concord grapevine. It gave me grapes that were as sweet as they were plentiful. It enjoyed being in the sunny spot I provided.

If you’re dreaming of grapes, the Concord grapevine might be the key to your sweet success.

19. Kiwi Plant

© Reddit

My first attempt at growing kiwis was a real head-scratcher. The plant just sat there, looking all leafy and stubborn, with barely a fruit in sight. I found myself wondering if it was just there for decoration.

Then, I gave the Hayward kiwi a try, and wow, what a difference! Placing it in a sunny, slightly sheltered spot seemed to be the magic trick. It took off, rewarding me with plenty of delicious kiwis.

If you’re hoping to grow your own kiwis, I can’t recommend the Hayward variety enough.

20. Olive Tree

© Reddit

Growing my first olive tree felt like chasing a miracle. It looked promising at first, but no matter how much I cared for it, there were barely any olives to show for my effort.

I tried the Arbequina olive tree, and everything changed. Planted in a sunny, well-drained spot, it absolutely thrived. Before I knew it, my garden was bursting with olives, giving me that Mediterranean vibe I’d been dreaming of.

If you’re hoping for a fruitful olive tree, I’d definitely go with the Arbequina. It turned my olive-growing struggle into a delicious success!

21. Almond Tree

© Reddit

This was my lesson in disappointment. I’d check on it, water it just right, and wait… and wait… but no almonds. I honestly started wondering if I’d ever get it right.

Then I decided to try the Nonpareil almond tree, and everything changed. It loved soaking up the sun in my yard and didn’t mind the dry soil. Before I knew it, I had more almonds than I knew what to do with. Seriously, I was handing them out to friends and neighbors just to keep my kitchen from overflowing.

The Nonpareil is the way to go. It turned my luck around. I wish I’d tried it sooner.

22. Chestnut Tree

© Reddit

My first chestnut tree was a total head-scratcher. I’d watch it all season long, hoping for some chestnuts, but nope—just a few sad leaves and nothing to show for my effort.

 Then I found the Chinese chestnut tree, and things finally turned around. I found it a sunny, slightly sheltered spot in the garden, and it absolutely thrived. Before I knew it, I was gathering up chestnuts by my hand.

If you’re dreaming of roasting your own chestnuts, the Chinese variety is the way to go. It saved me from a lot of frustration, and now I’ve got more chestnuts than I know what to do with.

23. Walnut Tree

© Reddit

My walnut tree was nothing but a letdown. I kept waiting for those delicious nuts, but all I got were a few branches and no walnuts in sight. I can’t tell you how many times I stood there, staring at it, wondering what went wrong.

I thought I should give Chandler walnut tree a try, and wow—what a difference. I planted it in a sunny spot, and it took off like it was making up for lost time.

The Chandler is a game-changer. It turned my frustration into a harvest I’m genuinely proud of.

24. Hazelnut Tree

© Reddit

This tree had me stumped. It looked healthy enough, but year after year, no hazelnuts. I’d check on it, hoping to see some sign of progress, but it was just leaves and more leaves.

Then, I tried the American hazelnut tree, and everything changed. I planted it in a sunny spot with a bit of shelter from the wind, and it just took off.

If you’re dreaming of your own homegrown hazelnuts, the American variety is a winner. It turned my gardening headache into a delicious harvest I couldn’t wait to share.

25. Pecan Tree

© Reddit

A real head-scratcher. It looked fine but stubbornly refused to give me a single pecan. I’d water it, check the soil, even talk to it (no judgment, please), but nothing seemed to work. It became my garden’s biggest mystery, and I started to think pecans just weren’t in my future.

Then, I tried planting a Pawnee pecan tree, and wow, what a difference! It settled into its sunny spot like it was meant to be there, and before long, it was dropping pecans faster than I could gather them.

I’d definitely recommend giving the Pawnee a shot. It saved me from my pecan dilemma.

26. Macadamia Tree

© Reddit

My first macadamia tree was a heartbreaker. It just sat there refusing to produce even one nut. I tried everything. Watering schedules, different fertilizers, even a pep talk or two—but nothing worked.

Then I planted a Beaumont macadamia tree, and let me tell you, it was a game-changer. It thrived in the sunny, well-drained spot I chose. It was loaded with delicious macadamias. I finally had my own supply of these tasty nuts.

If you’re dreaming of having your own macadamias, the Beaumont is definitely worth a try.

27. Pistachio Tree

© gfreefoodie

I really thought I could crack the code with my first pistachio tree, but it turned out to be more of a garden ornament than anything else. No nuts, just a bunch of branches that left me questioning my gardening skills.

Everything changed when I planted a Kerman pistachio tree. Tucked into a sunny, slightly sheltered spot, it finally gave me the harvest I’d been dreaming of. Watching those pistachios grow felt like magic after all the frustration.

The Kerman variety might just surprise you. It certainly did for me.

28. Cashew Tree

© Reddit

I had high hopes for my first cashew tree, but it turned out to be a real head-scratcher. Not a single nut in sight. Just a stubborn reminder of my gardening misadventures.

Then I planted a Cashew apple tree. It thrived in the sunny corner of my garden, finally delivering the cashews I’d been craving. It felt like a small victory every time I saw those nuts growing.

If you’re dreaming of fresh cashews, the Cashew apple tree might just be the game-changer you need. It certainly turned things around for me.

29. Coconut Palm

© Reddit

I used to daydream about sipping fresh coconut water from my own garden, but my first coconut palm had other ideas. It stubbornly refused to produce a single coconut.

Everything changed when I tried a Dwarf coconut palm. It settled nicely into the sunny corner of my garden and finally delivered the coconuts I’d been longing for.

If you’re chasing that tropical vibe like I was, the Dwarf coconut palm might just be your ticket to paradise. It might make your dream a reality.

30. Date Palm

© Reddit

I thought growing my own dates would be a sweet dream come true, but my first date palm had other plans. It just stood there with its lack of fruit. I was beginning to think it was just an expensive piece of garden decor.

Things finally changed when I brought home a Medjool date palm. Planted in a sunny, well-drained spot, it rewarded me with the sweetest dates I could’ve hoped for. Snacking on them straight from the tree felt like a bonus.

If you want that homegrown dessert experience, give the Medjool a try.

31. Guava Tree

© Reddit

My first attempt at growing guavas was a lesson in patience… and disappointment. I watched that tree like a hawk, hoping for even a single fruit, but nothing.

Things took a sweet turn when I switched to a Pineapple guava tree. It settled into a sunny, slightly sheltered spot and surprised me with a harvest that made all the effort worthwhile. Finally, I was picking flavorful guavas instead of questioning my gardening skills.

The Pineapple variety could be the game-changer you need.

32. Lychee Tree

© Reddit

That lychee tree really had me questioning my gardening skills. I’d eagerly watch its sparse leaves, waiting for even a hint of fruit, but it just wouldn’t deliver. Every season ended in disappointment.

I gave the Brewster lychee tree a shot, and wow, what a difference! It filled out beautifully under the warm sun, and the fruits were not only plentiful but unbelievably sweet. It was like the tree had been waiting to show off.

So, I’d definitely recommend the Brewster. It turned my fruitless struggle into a delicious success.

33. Mulberry Tree

© Reddit

I spent so many mornings staring at that mulberry tree, hoping for even a hint of fruit. It stood there, stubbornly leafing out but refusing to give me a single berry. I started to think it was mocking me.

Switching to the Black mulberry tree was the best decision I made. It settled into that sunny spot like it was meant to be there, and soon enough, it was overflowing with sweet, juicy mulberries. Finally, all that waiting paid off.

If you’re tired of empty branches and broken berry dreams, give the Black variety a try.